Bretagne by far - classic design, nice layout and good seakeeping qualities (in my experience anyway!) - Barfleur second as she is our 'local' ship (I live in Poole!). Can't get on with the layout of Armorique - the public areas just felt too much like a ferry! I know that's a weird comment but feel a second restaurant option for more upmarket dining, as well as a quieter more restful bar would not go amiss for the longer crossings! Just my opinion. I do also rate MSM highly for her décor and facilities. Finally, I recently travelled on Normandie for the first time and again was very impressed, just a shame the fitting of the exhaust scrubbers have spoiled her overall appearance!